| Availability List - 2008 Scandalous League Fulfillment Draft | |||||
| Back in the 2008 Draft: | Not eligible to be taken by Dave or Craig until Draft Day | ||||
| Bedard (SEA) | Figgins (LAA) | Haren (AZ) | Kazmir (TAM) | Myers (PHI) | Sizemore (CLE) |
| Berkman (HOU) | Francoeur (ATL) | Hernandez (SEA) | Lee (CHI) | Roberts (BAL) | Street (OAK) |
| Damon (NYY) | Glaus (STL) | Holliday (COL) | Lowry (SF) | Ryan (TOR) | Utley (PHI) |
| Dye (CWS) | Halladay (TOR) | Howard (PHI) | Mauer (MIN) | Schmidt (LAD) | Willis (DET) |
| Back in the 2009 Draft: | |||||
| 1 Tejada (HOU) | 2 Rivera (NYY) | 6 Wickman (ARI) | 13 Olsen (FLA) | 17 Ibanez (SEA) | 21 Borowski (CLE) |
| 2 Delgado (NYM) | 3 Furcal (LAD) | 7 Bonderman (DET) | 13 Sanchez (FLA) | 17 Ramirez (FLA) | 22 McCann (ATL) |
| 2 Harden (OAK) | 4 Hoffman (SD) | 10 Ray (BAL) | 14 Lowe (LAD) | 19 Swisher (CWS) | 23 Barfield (CLE) |
| 2 Jones (ATL) | 4 Thome (CWS) | 13 Arroyo (CIN) | 16 Greene (SD) | 20 Monroe (MIN) | |
| 2 Reyes (NYM) | 5 Zito (SF) | 13 Hall (MIL) | 17 Baldelli (TAM) | 20 Patterson (CIN) | |
| Back in the 2010 Draft: | |||||
| 1 Carpenter (STL) | 8 Pettitte (NYY) | 13F Accardo (TOR) | 13F Hermida (FLA) | 13F Torrealba (COL) | 19 Paulino (PIT) |
| 1 Oswalt (HOU) | 9 Cabrera (CWS) | 13F Baker (MIN) | 13F Hernandez (NYM) | 13F Vidro (SEA) | 19M Buchholz (BOS) |
| 2 Hafner (CLE) | 9 Cuddyer (MIN) | 13F Bannister (KAN) | 13F Hill (TOR) | 13F Wakefield (BOS) | 19M Maybin (FLA) |
| 3 Abreu (NYY) | 9 Garcia (PHI) | 13F Batista (SEA) | 13F Jenkins (PHI) | 13F Weathers (CIN) | 19M Votto (CIN) |
| 3 Konerko (CWS) | 9 Garciaparra (LAD) | 13F Blake (CLE) | 13F Johnson (ATL) | 13F Wolf (SD) | 20 Estrada (WAS) |
| 3 Wells (TOR) | 9 Isringhausen (STL) | 13F Buck (KAN) | 13F Adam Jones (BAL) | 13F Young (WAS) | 20 Guillen (KC) |
| 4 Pierre (LAD) | 9 T. Jones (DET) | 13F Cabrera (NYY) | 13F Lester (BOS) | 13F Zaun (TOR) | 20 Johnson (FLA) |
| 4 Rolen (TOR) | 9 Thomas (TOR) | 13F Capps (PIT) | 13F Marcum (TOR) | 14 Millwood (TEX) | 20 Ross (CIN) |
| 4 Schilling (BOS) | 10 Cameron (MIL) | 13F Chamberlain (NYY) | 13F Marshall (CHI) | 14 Youkilis (BOS) | 20 Sanchez (PIT) |
| 4 Sexson (SEA) | 10 Hudson (ARI) | 13F Cust (OAK) | 13F Matsui (HOU) | 15 Broxton (LAD) | 20 Snell (PIT) |
| 4 Sheffield (DET) | 10 Patterson (WAS) | 13F Davis (ARI) | 13F Meche (KAN) | 15 Crisp (BOS) | 20M Fields (CWS) |
| 4 Young (TEX) | 10 Rodriguez (DET) | 13F DeJesus (KAN) | 13F Milledge (WAS) | 15 Molina (SF) | 20M McCutchen (PIT) |
| 5 Burnett (TOR) | 10 Valverde (HOU) | 13F Doumit (PIT) | 13F Nady (PIT) | 15 Overbay (TOR) | 20M Perkins (MIN) |
| 5 Cordero (WAS) | 11 Burrell (PHI) | 13F Duchscherer (OAK) | 13F Okajima (BOS) | 15 Varitek (BOS) | 21 Alou (NYM) |
| 5 Johnson (ARI) | 11 Duncan (STL) | 13F Ellis (OAK) | 13F Pavano (NYY) | 15 Willingham (FLA) | 21 Kearns (WAS) |
| 5 Jones (ATL) | 11 Hernandez (BAL) | 13F Ethier (LAD) | 13F Pedroia (BOS) | 15 Zumaya (DET) | 22 Bard (SD) |
| 5 Matsui (NYY) | 11 Kent (LAD) | 13F Francis (COL) | 13F Pineiro (STL) | 16 Blanton (OAK) | 22 Griffey Jr (CIN) |
| 6 Drew (BOS) | 11 Lilly (CHI) | 13F Gabbard (TEX) | 13F Polanco (DET) | 16 Dempster (CHI) | 22 Kendall (MIL) |
| 6 Escobar (LAA) | 11 Pierzynski (CWS) | 13F Garko (CLE) | 13F Rodriguez (HOU) | 16 Teahen (KAN) | 22 Lo Duca (WAS) |
| 6 Helton (COL) | 11 Taveras (COL) | 13F Gaudin (OAK) | 13F Rogers (DET) | 17 Otsuka (TEX) | 22 Napoli (LAA) |
| 6 Renteria (DET) | 12 Bush (MIL) | 13F Gonzalez (FLA) | 13F Rowand (SF) | 18M Bailey (CIN) | 22 Wigginton (HOU) |
| 7 Beltre (SEA) | 12 Gagne (MIL) | 13F Greinke (KAN) | 13F Ruiz (PHI) | 18M Garza (TB) | 23 Bonser (MIN) |
| 7 Buehrle (CWS) | 12 Matthews (LAA) | 13F Guthrie (BAL) | 13F Saltalamacchia (TEX) | 18M Hughes (NYY) | 23 Bradley (TEX) |
| 7 LaRoche (PIT) | 12 Podsednik (COL) | 13F Hamilton (TEX) | 13F Shields (TAM) | 18M Miller (FLA) | 23 Maddux (SD) |
| 8 Chavez (OAK) | 13 Eckstein (TOR) | 13F Hardy (MIL) | 13F Suzuki (OAK) | 18M Wood (LAA) | 23 Olivo (FLA) |
| 8 Durham (SF) | 13 Glavine (ATL) | 13F Hennessey (SF) | 13F Theriot (CHI) | 19 Giambi (NYY) | |